Incorporating Participatory Science in Elementary Schools Teacher and Student Experiences with Outdoor Learning

Main Article Content

Sarah J Carrier
Danielle Scharen
Meredith Hayes
P. Sean Smith
Chris Goforth
Laura Craven
Lindsey Sachs

Abstract

Science instruction in elementary school provides a base for student understanding of the natural world, yet policies prioritizing mathematics and reading have marginalized science. In response, some teachers have enhanced their science instruction by introducing students to participatory science (PS) projects. Using data from a larger study that examines the development of educative support materials for two existing PS projects, this embedded mixed methods study focuses on teachers’ and students’ experiences learning outdoors. We compare teachers’ weekly log data, surveys, interviews, observations, and student focus groups to document teachers’ applications of PS in their science classrooms and outdoors. Teachers report benefits (e.g., purposeful science learning) and challenges (e.g., time constraints, testing pressure) of implementing outdoor PS projects. Teacher and student data document cognitive and affective benefits of students’ participation. Implications support the potential for PS projects that include schoolyard activities to supplement elementary science teaching and learning.

Article Details

Section
Research / Empirical
Author Biographies

Danielle Scharen, Horizon Research, Inc.

Danielle R. Scharen, Lead Researcher at Horizon Research, Inc. (HRI), received a Bachelor of Science degree in Elementary Education with a concentration in STEM Education, a Master of Education degree in Elementary Education with a Science Leadership concentration, and a Ph.D. in Teacher Education and Learning Sciences with a concentration in Elementary Science Education from North Carolina State University. Prior to joining HRI in 2023, Dr. Scharen taught undergraduate science education courses at North Carolina State University and was an elementary school teacher in Wake County Public Schools. Her dissertation research focused on methods for integrating science and literacy in the elementary school classroom and evaluated preservice teachers’ use of a science instructional model that supports students’ development of science skills, discourse practices, language development, and reading and writing skills. Dr. Scharen has worked on several research and evaluation projects since joining HRI including the OpenSciEd Elementary Field Test; Supporting Elementary Teacher Learning for Effective School-Based Citizen Science (TL4CS); NEXUS Academy for Science Curriculum Leadership (NEXUS); and Engaging Minoritized Populations in Environmental Action through Mentoring, Geospatial Technology & Digital Media Storytelling (ECO-DIG).

Meredith Hayes, Horizon Research, Inc.

Meredith L. Hayes, independent consultant in education research and evaluation, received her Bachelor’s degree in Elementary Education from Wake Forest University. Her work in STEM education research and evaluation began at Horizon Research, Inc. in Chapel Hill, and she has worked on several projects funded by the National Science Foundation and the NASA Science Mission Directorate, both as a researcher and external evaluator. In addition, she has taught upper elementary grades and served as the school mathematics/science specialist, working with K-5 students and teachers. Her current work focuses on investigating how teachers implement citizen science projects at the elementary level.

P. Sean Smith, Horizon Research, Inc.

Patrick Sean Smith, President of Horizon Research, Inc. (HRI), received a Bachelor’s Degree in Chemistry, a Master’s Degree in Science Teaching, and a Ph.D. in Curriculum and Instruction. Before joining HRI in 1991, Dr. Smith taught high school chemistry and physics. In addition, he was a member of the Education Studies Department at Berea College, where he taught courses in elementary science methods and the philosophical foundations of education. Dr. Smith was the Principal Investigator of ATLAST (Assessing Teacher Learning About Science Teaching), a project that created instruments that are widely used by researchers and evaluators to measure teacher and student science content knowledge. He was also the Principal Investigator for the NSF-funded Knowledge Assets to Support the Science Instruction of Elementary Teachers (ASSET) project. He was a co-Principal Investigator on four NSF-funded projects: Assessing the Impact of the MSPs: K-8 Science (AIM: K-8 Science); Investigating Teachers’ Learning, Practice, and Efficacy Using Educative Curriculum Materials (ELECTS); and the 2012 and 2018 NSSMEs. He is currently Principal Investigator for the NSF-funded Supporting Elementary Teacher Learning for Effective School-Based Citizen Science (TL4CS). Dr. Smith also leads the evaluations of several projects funded by NSF and the US Department of Education.

Lindsey Sachs, Horizon Research, Inc.

Lindsey H. Sachs, Research Associate at Horizon Research, Inc. (HRI), received her Bachelor of Arts degree in Elementary Education from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and a Master of Education degree from North Carolina State University.  Prior to joining HRI in 2020, she served as the academically and intellectually gifted coordinator for her school and taught at the elementary level. Ms. Sachs has worked on several evaluation projects during her time at HRI, including Professional Development to Support an Elementary School Science and Integrated Language Curriculum (SAIL-ON), Using Technology to Capture Classroom Interactions (UTTCI), a validity study of the Math Habits Tool, and Mathematics through Programming in the Elementary Grades (Math+C).